Stillbirth is a profoundly devastating experience for families, leaving emotional scars that often last a lifetime. Each year 24,000 stillbirths happen in the United States. Disturbingly, the U.S. has a higher stillbirth rate than many other developed nations, more than doubling the rate in countries like Iceland. This disparity underscores that many stillbirths are preventable with proper treatment and care.
The Legal Challenges in Addressing Stillbirths
Despite the profound emotional and financial toll of stillbirths, families often encounter significant legal challenges when seeking compensation and recovery for a stillbirth injury caused by the negligence of another. One of the primary issues lies in the disparity between how the law addresses stillbirths compared to birth injuries.
In cases of birth injury, parents can sue for damages to cover the lifelong care needs of the child. However, in stillbirth cases, where the baby has died prior to delivery, there is often no ongoing care required, and the lack of tangible financial losses affects the proof of damages available.
Preventable Stillbirths and Medical Negligence
The World Health Organization reports that half of all stillbirths occur during labor, often to full-term infants who would have otherwise been expected to survive. Preventable stillbirths are frequently linked to complications involving the umbilical cord or placenta, or maternal health conditions such as diabetes, high blood pressure, and obesity. Such issues also contribute to maternal mortality and birth injuries, disproportionately affecting socially disadvantaged and minority women.
Even in advanced medical facilities, preventable stillbirths can occur due to errors like mismanaging high-risk pregnancies, failing to monitor signs of fetal distress, or understaffing. When these errors result in stillbirth, medical malpractice may have occurred. However, families pursuing malpractice claims often face additional hurdles in demonstrating causation and securing compensation.
Is a Stillborn Baby a Person?
In Virginia, a stillborn baby was not traditionally considered a “person” under the state’s wrongful death statute. Historically, Virginia courts have held that an unborn child, even if viable, does not qualify as a “person” for the purposes of wrongful death claims. To wit, in the 1969 case, Lawrence v. Craven Tire Co., the Virginia Supreme Court ruled that no action will lie under Virginia law for the wrongful death of a stillborn child.1
In Modaber v. Kelley, 232 Va. 60 (1986), the Virginia Supreme Court later clarified that the mother could claim her emotional distress for the loss of her unborn child as part of her own claim.
However, in 2012, the Virginia General Assembly amended the wrongful death statute to allow a cause of action for “fetal death,” defined as death prior to complete expulsion or extraction from the mother, regardless of the duration of pregnancy.2 This amendment permits the natural mother to bring an action for the wrongful death of her fetus.
Since the 2012 amendment to the law, Virginia provides a specific cause of action for fetal death, enabling the mother to seek damages for the loss of her unborn child. Those damages include full wrongful death damages, such as medical expenses, funeral bills, and emotional suffering for both parents and any siblings of the stillborn fetus.
Emotional and Financial Costs of Stillbirth
Stillbirths cause immense emotional distress, often leading to symptoms of depression, strained relationships, and stigma. Financially, families may face costs for postmortem testing, mental health treatment, and time away from work. Despite these significant impacts, damages awarded in stillbirth cases are frequently capped at levels that fail to reflect the profound loss experienced.
Additionally, the cost of litigating stillbirth cases can be expensive. Attorneys must often rely on expert witnesses in prenatal and obstetrical care, increasing baseline expenses. These costs should be discussed with an experienced medical malpractice attorney.
Seeking Justice and Support
Families grieving a stillbirth caused by medical negligence deserve accountability and answers. Consulting with experienced medical malpractice attorneys can help with this complex legal landscape and explore potential avenues for justice. If your family has suffered a stillbirth that is suspected to have been caused by negligence or medical malpractice, contact us for a free, compassionate case evaluation: (703) 638-7717.
___________________________________________________________
Sources:
- Lawrence v. Craven Tire Co., Virginia Supreme Court. Available here https://law.justia.com/cases/virginia/supreme-court/1990/890307-1.html
- Virginia Code § 8.01-50, amended in 2012. Available here: https://law.lis.virginia.gov/vacode/title8.01/chapter3/section8.01-50
Read Next
- Virginia’s Wrongful Death Act overview
- Preserving evidence after a wrongful death
- Autopsy report for a Virginia wrongful death claim
- Virginia Wrongful Death Guide
This article is part of our Virginia Wrongful Death Guide
Disclaimer: These articles and related guide provide general information about Virginia wrongful death cases. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney–client relationship. Laws, deadlines, and procedures vary by case. Virginia wrongful death actions must be filed through an attorney; consult a licensed Virginia lawyer about your specific situation.







