To win a medical malpractice case in Maryland, expert testimony is usually required to prove that the doctor breached the standard of care. Maryland has rules that apply to the qualifications for doctors to be expert witnesses in malpractice cases.
Remember that this is information is offered for educational purposes only. It is not legal advice and reading this content or any content offered on this website does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Maryland Qualifications for Expert Witnesses
First, the expert who signs the Certificate of Qualified Expert (and any expert who later testifies on standard of care) must be a health care provider with clinical experience, consultation, or teaching experience in the same field as the defendant, or a related field, within five years of the alleged incident, as required by Maryland law.
Board Certified Defendants
If the defendant doctor is board-certified in a specialty, the plaintiff’s expert is generally expected by courts to be board-certified in the same (or a closely related) specialty. (The only exception is if the defendant was treating the patient for something outside their board specialty, or the expert taught medicine in the defendant’s specialty.)
These rules prevent a situation where, say, a dermatologist tries to testify about the standard of care for a heart surgeon – only qualified peers can opine on whether the defendant doctor violated medical standards.
Maryland’s 25% Rule
Maryland also enacted what’s known as the “20% rule,” now a 25% rule, to exclude potential witnesses who testify frequently. Under Courts & Judicial Proceedings § 3-2A-04(b), an expert who testifies about standard of care in court or signs a certificate must not devote more than 25% of their professional time to legal testimony work. (This was tightened from an older 20% rule in 2019.)
In practice, this means your medical expert should spend at least 75% of their time in actual clinical practice or teaching, and no more than 25% as an expert witness.
Plaintiffs’ attorneys must be careful in choosing their experts. Maryland courts enforce this rule strictly at the certificate stage. A certificate from an expert who violates the 25% rule is invalid, potentially torpedoing the case. Defense lawyers can and do inquire into an expert’s income and time spent on forensics to try to show non-compliance, so they can disqualify them from testifying. The rule is checked by looking at the expert’s activities in the 12 months before the claim was filed.
Why Are There Expert Witness Rules in Maryland?
Maryland’s expert witness rules are supposedly designed to ensure that only truly qualified and credible medical professionals testify in malpractice cases. However, there is a secondary effect that is not accidental. These rules make it harder for injured Maryland patients to find potential experts, as compared to the rules that apply in Washington, DC.
Recently retired doctors are often a great source for potential experts. They know their stuff, have the right experience, but do not have the time constraints imposed by a full clinical practice. While a retired doctor can serve as an expert in Maryland, the 25% rule will eventually disqualify them if they do not have other professional activities.
Finding the right expert is critical to your Maryland medical malpractice case. An experienced malpractice attorney, like those at Wallace Wason, PLLC, will vet potential experts to make sure they meet Maryland’s requirements (clinical experience, same board certification, not over 25% legal work, etc.) before relying on them.
How Wallace Wason Can Help
Wallace Wason, PLLC is experienced in medical and dental malpractice cases – all requiring expert certification, as well as wrongful death and personal injury. We can help find qualified experts to review your case, and provide the necessary certification so the case can be filed. Contact us today to find out more about how we can help you. (703) 638-7717.
If you have been seriously hurt, we will help you make a serious recovery.®







