Beating the Collectability Defense in Virginia Legal Malpractice Cases

Nov 11, 2024 | Legal Malpractice

In Virginia legal malpractice cases, one of the most common defenses raised by attorneys is the “collectability” defense. This defense centers around a general legal principle: a client can only recover damages for what the attorney actually cost them.

If the underlying case—the one the lawyer was originally handling—was weak or likely to fail, then even if the lawyer’s negligence was substantial, the client may not recover much, if anything. In essence, if you weren’t going to win much (or anything) in damages anyway, the lawyer’s negligence did not harm you financially.

The Collectability Defense and Its Burden

The collectability defense argues that, even if an attorney was negligent in handling the original case, the client wasn’t harmed because the case would not have resulted in a collectible judgment. One key aspect of Virginia law here is that it is the defense’s burden to prove that the underlying case was no good. The legal malpractice defendant attorney must show that even if they had handled the case properly, the client wouldn’t have recovered anything substantial. 

In the Virginia Supreme Court’s McLaughlin case, the collectability defense was a focal point. The court highlighted the requirement for the legal malpractice defendant attorney to demonstrate that the underlying case had little or no value.  

The legal malpractice plaintiff still needs to prove that they had a good underlying case. For example, for an underlying car crash case, the legal malpractice plaintiff needs to prove how the crash happened because of someone else’s fault, that they were injured, and the extent of their damages. They just do not need to prove that there was insurance to cover the other driver or that the other driver had assets to personally pay a judgment.  

The Challenge for the Defense

One of the inherent challenges for the defense in legal malpractice cases involving the collectability argument is the contradictory nature of their position. Often, the same attorney who is now defending the malpractice claim is the one who originally took the case and assured the client it had merit. They may have led the client to believe throughout the course of litigation that it was a strong case. Now, the defense must argue the opposite: that the case was not worth much, or that there was little chance of winning substantial damages. 

This shift in stance can introduce complications for the legal malpractice defendant attorney. Statements made during the original case can come back to haunt them as they attempt to argue that the case wasn’t as strong as they initially claimed. This often leads to a tangled web of conflicting evidence, some of which may be considered hearsay, weakening the defense’s argument. 

Proving Value and Overcoming the Defense

For the plaintiff—the client bringing the legal malpractice case—the key to overcoming the collectability defense is showing that, but for the attorney’s negligence, there was a reasonable chance of success in the original case. Evidence that the attorney took the case and argued its merits throughout is often helpful in proving this point. Additionally, documents and expert testimony showing the potential value of the underlying claim can be instrumental in countering the collectability defense. 

In Virginia, plaintiffs in legal malpractice cases can also present expert witnesses to testify to the potential outcome of the original case. These experts can help establish that, despite what the defense claims, the underlying case had merit and was worth pursuing, making the attorney’s negligence financially harmful. 

Conclusion

The collectability defense in Virginia legal malpractice cases can be an issue for plaintiffs, but it is not insurmountable. By focusing on the defendant attorney’s burden to prove that the original case was weak, and by highlighting the contradictions in the attorney’s arguments, plaintiffs can weaken the defense. Moreover, careful documentation and expert testimony can show that the underlying case had value, making it clear that the attorney’s negligence did, in fact, cause financial harm. 

In situations like these, having a seasoned legal malpractice attorney like those at Wallace Wason, PLLC is essential to navigate the complexities of the collectability defense and ensure that your case is presented in the best possible light. 

This article is part of our Virginia Legal Malpractice Guide.

Disclaimer: These articles and related guide provide general information about Virginia legal malpractice cases. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney–client relationship. Laws, deadlines, and procedures vary by case. Consult a licensed Virginia lawyer about your specific situation.

 

If You Have Been Seriously Hurt, We Will Help You Make a Serious Recovery®

Disclaimer: Reading the content on this site, contacting us by text, phone or email or submitting a form through this website does not create an attorney-client relationship. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice. Case results do not guarantee or predict a similar result in any future cases undertaken.

Related Articles

Are you Ready to Make a Serious Recovery?